Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Robin Douglas's avatar

Clerical attitudes to astrology are an interesting subject in their own right. The idea that astrology is impermissible because it can't be reconciled with free will came to be held in the Catholic West too. This still left room for predicting things that weren't dependent on free will, such as a person's health. It was also believed that it was acceptable to predict the behaviour of *large numbers* of people through astrology because, while each individual among them had free will, it was reasonable to say that general patterns of behaviour would assert themselves across a population. So, for example, you could use a horoscope to predict whether a nation would launch a rebellion. You could also use a birth chart to make *broad conjectures* about a person's actions, as long as you didn't claim that they were definite predictions. This is all a classic example of the pedantry of Catholic moral theology, and it would be interesting to know if Orthodox clerics descended into this level of hairsplitting.

Expand full comment
Pete Prochilo's avatar

Thanks for this. I believe the numbering system for days is also employed in Portuguese, a break from the other Latin languages.

That sense of spirality suggests the unfolding of Logos, his continual disclosure in time and space.

Are there any correspondences or resonances here for, say, the Liturgy of the Hours? Thanks again.

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts